Boom Lift vs. Scissor Lift - Pros and Cons of Two Height ...

Please visit our website for more information on this topic.

Your upcoming project requires a work-at-heights lift rental that you’ve narrowed down to a boom lift vs. scissor lift. Which one is best suited for your budget and is the most efficient? Let’s break it down, exploring the pros and cons of each. But first, let’s revisit their definitions and types.

Key Definitions for Boom lifts and Scissor lifts

What is a Boom Lift?

A boom lift, often referred to as a man lift, cherry picker, or elevated work platform, operates hydraulically and serves as the highest-reaching elevated work mechanism. The basket is raised using an extending arm controlled from the base of the machine. Boom lifts are designed to provide efficient, reliable, and safe access at great heights, allowing workers to be raised and moved both horizontally and vertically for various tasks indoors and outdoors.

There are two types of Boom Lifts:

1. Articulating Boom and Telescopic Articulating boom lifts feature jointed arms that bend at one or more places, providing exceptional reach and flexibility, often identified as knuckle booms due to their knuckle-like connectors. The 360-degree turntable enables rotation in both directions.
2. Telescopic boom lifts, also known as straight or stick boom lifts, have a long, straight arm that doesn’t bend. A telescopic boom lift may have limited flexibility but can reach higher than an articulating boom lift and allows side-to-side movement, with the ability to access hard-to-reach locations.

Alpha Platforms' hybrid boom lifts can reach heights up to 300 feet.

What is a Scissor Lift?

A scissor lift employs an X-like crisscrossing brace design to elevate the platform with workers. These lifts can only move vertically but tend to be larger and accommodate more weight. The operational base needs stable ground for optimal functionality, and scissor lifts generally do not exceed a height of 60 feet.

Two types of scissor lifts:

1. Electric and Engine-powered Electric scissor lifts are designed to operate in enclosed spaces with zero emissions and are silent. Engine-powered scissor lifts are diesel-powered, suitable for outdoor environments with higher load capacity (up to 2,250 lbs) and larger platform areas (79 x 154 in. / 1.95 x 3.92 m) designed for uneven surfaces.

Boom Lift Vs. Scissor Lift

Boom Lifts Pros

• Exceptional maneuverability in hard-to-reach environments.
• Spacious 12-ft cage for working comfortably.
• Maximum cage-lifting capacity of 1,540 lbs.
• Greater lift heights up to 300 feet.
• Side outreach capabilities reaching up to 135 feet.

Boom Lifts Cons

• Limited worker capacity in the basket.
• Typically higher rental costs compared to scissor lifts.

Scissor Lifts Pros

• Generous platform size for multiple workers (6’4” x 13’).
• A maximum platform load capacity of up to 2,250 lbs.
• Generally more economical than boom lifts.

Scissor Lifts Cons

• Shorter lifting capabilities, maxing out at 60 feet.
• Vertical movement only, thus lacking side reach.
• Must be positioned directly below or adjacent to the work area.

Boom Lift vs. Scissor Lift: Key Features

Boom Lifts:

• Efficient at substantial heights.
• Enhanced maneuverability for inaccessible locations.
• Turning capabilities ideal for navigating around structures.
• "Up and over" access that can extend 200 feet vertically and 100 feet horizontally.
• Smooth operation for working near sensitive structures.

Scissor Lifts:

• Provides safe elevation of workers up to 50 ft.
• Compact footprint due to unit size.
• Designed with ergonomic controls for ease of use.
• Stable platforms with large basket capacity (versus boom lifts).

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Scissor Lift vs. Boom Lift

While every project's nuances can't be captured, we've outlined key factors to contemplate when deciding between a boom lift and a scissor lift.

Top 6 Factors When Choosing Boom Lifts vs. Scissor Lifts

1. Height
2. Direction
3. Obstacles
4. Location
5. Number of Workers
6. Budget

Think about the required height and how boom lifts compare to scissor lifts. Scissor lift platforms typically do not exceed 60 feet, making them ideal for residential and indoor tasks. In contrast, boom lifts provide significantly higher access, with telescopic options reaching upwards of 300 feet, often used for commercial cleaning, cell tower repairs, and construction projects.

1. Assess Directional Needs: If your work involves only vertical motion, a scissor lift may be sufficient. For tasks requiring extensive mobility or maneuvering around obstacles, boom lifts are ideal, showcasing their flexibility for challenging areas.
2. Consider Obstacles: Scissor lifts' strict vertical movements limit their ability to navigate around structures, whereas boom lifts, with their impressive side reach of nearly 135 feet, can operate over various terrains more efficiently.
3. Evaluate Location Suitability: Scissor lifts excel in stable indoor environments, particularly if floors are delicate. Boom lifts, larger and heavier, must align with building management guidelines but can handle uneven terrains adeptly.
4. How Many Workers to Accommodate: Historically, boom lifts catered to one person and their tools. Thanks to advancements like Alpha Platforms' spacious work cage accommodating 6-7 people with a 1,360 lbs capacity, they have become preferred by professionals. For carrying heavy materials with multiple personnel, scissor lifts stand out due to their robust platforms.
5. Consider Your Budget: Boom lifts generally command a higher rental price due to their versatility and operational efficiency at elevated heights. If your project requires under 50 feet of reach, a scissor lift can be a cost-effective solution.

Oftentimes, while a scissor lift may serve part of your project, your needs might ultimately require a boom lift. This is where the selection between these two equipment types presents challenges.

Fortunately, Alpha Platforms addresses this issue by providing solutions suitable for urban work environments and challenging sites. Our compact design and exceptional maneuverability make our boom lifts an ideal choice, potentially cutting costs compared to hiring both a scissor and boom lift.

With competitive pricing and prompt delivery, Wonder Machinery aims to be your trusted supplier and partner.

Scissor Lift vs. Boom Lift: Q&A

Do I Need a License to Operate Boom Lifts vs. Scissor Lifts?

All operators of scissor and boom lifts are required to be licensed and trained. OSHA (Occupational Safety and Health Administration) mandates that lift operators complete a specialized certification process.

How Much Do Boom Lifts vs. Scissor Lifts Weigh?

Scissor lifts can weigh between 8,000-17,000 lbs, depending on height capacity. For electric models, account for both lift and load weight. The heaviest 300-ft boom lift weighs approximately 110,900 lbs; smaller 120-ft models weigh around 19,500 lbs.

All Alpha Platforms' boom lifts vary in weight, averaging comparable to that of a firetruck and adhering to all US road standards. When operating indoors, ensure that the surface can support the load. Some of Alpha Platforms' boom lifts are even certified for indoor applications.

Can a Scissor Lift Tip Over?

Both lift types may tip under unfavorable conditions or improper use, especially if the load is off-center or a worker leans incorrectly. Ensure stabilization measures and adhere to safety and operational guidelines for scissor lifts.

Alpha Platforms' boom lifts incorporate factory-installed safety systems designed to mitigate tipping risks.

What Projects Are Best Suited for Boom Lifts?

• Cleaning and maintenance
• Sign installation and removal
• Commercial painting
• Utilities and electrical tasks
• Cellular antenna projects
• Bulb replacement jobs
• Tree cutting and trimming
• Bird protection efforts
• Demolition tasks
• Roof surveys
• Building façade inspections
• Facade repair work
• Aerial photography
• Pest control efforts
• Glazing and window repair tasks
• General construction activities
• HVAC and duct work
• Film and television production
• Stadium and arena setup
• Airport projects
• Highway and bridge inspections

What Is Your Next Step?
Having evaluated the core elements, features, and benefits of boom lifts versus scissor lifts, and in light of the crucial factors guiding your aerial platform choice, you can now proceed with a well-informed decision.

If You Decide a Boom Lift Meets Your Needs, Alpha Platforms Provides a Range of Lifts Suitable for Most Projects.

Have You Tried Operated Boom Lift Rentals?
Alpha Platforms offers a hassle-free, all-inclusive access solution for inspection, maintenance, repairs, and other height-related projects.

• IPAF-certified, fully-trained operators.
• Our German-engineered aerial platforms comply with US codes and standards.
• Exceptional service including permit management and traffic coordination.

Read more about Operated Rentals or call now at 855--855

Alpha Platforms leads the industry in operated boom lift rentals and high-access services in the 150-300-ft class. Our precise, German-built lifts have gained a reputation as the preferred method for height access due to unmatched productivity, safety, and reach.

Discover why Alpha Platforms is the ultimate choice for height access solutions.

Learn how Alpha Platforms effectively eliminates owner liability.

Compare JLG vs. Alpha Platforms.